Now that I have voted, here are my final thoughts on the 2020 Presidential election:
As I write on October 29th, 2020, many polls seem to
be indicating a movement toward a Biden victory next week—but who knows? One
thing that does seem pretty certain is that those people in the U.S. who are expressing
opinions are deeply divided. While the campaign does not feel to me like it is as
contentious and nasty as 2016, I cannot say whether that is because the tone is
actually less abrasive, or whether our sense of civil propriety has been numbed
over the past four years to the point where muddy looks clean.
Either way things turn out I am concerned. If Donald Trump is
re-elected, I am concerned that, at best, we will get more of what we have seen
the past four years: the same incivility;
the same indifference to the poor and disenfranchised; the same intolerance of
differences of opinion; the same hostility toward immigrants and those who have
labored for generations under the weight of racial and economic disparity; and
the same disengagement from international commitments and cooperation. If he is
re-elected, I am not sure that there is anything he could say that would allay
my concerns.
If Joe Biden is elected, I am concerned about how far the pendulum
will swing. While I can no longer support what the Republican party seems to
have become, I also cannot fully embrace the Democratic platform—and that gives
me pause. What would allay my concerns—and garner my full support—is if Joe
Biden were to lay out just three priorities for his administration:
1.
Address and deal
with the coronavirus pandemic. This would involve
supporting health care workers and the development of an effective vaccine; implementing
policies and approaches to public gatherings and personal behavior to slow the
spread of the virus; and sufficient federal economic assistance so that when we
emerge from under the cloud of the pandemic, we are economically viable enough
to be able to work toward recovery and reduction of the debt we have incurred.
2.
Focus efforts toward
making our national motto—e pluribus unum (out of many, one)—a reality. This would involve meaningful work to understand and address disparities
in opportunity and achievement based on race, economic, and immigration status;
meaningful and humane immigration reform that prioritizes legal immigration and
clarifies refugee considerations; and civics education that promotes knowledgeable,
respectful public discourse.
3.
Refresh the United
States’ place in the global community of nations. This would involve restoring the view and practice that the
United States is a reliable and trusted friend and ally—as well as an honest and
determined adversary; and re-engaging with other nations on equitable trade, human
rights, and climate concerns.
If a Biden administration could get us on track with real movement
related to these three priorities, I believe that his presidency would be both a
short- and the long-term success worth celebrating.
My “nightmare” scenario is that when this election cycle is over,
the American people remain as polarized, divided, and entrenched as now—whether
due to the actions and words of the vanquished or the victor; or the
unwillingness to accept that “our” candidate came up short in the bigger,
state-wide and national picture.
I cannot control what anyone else thinks or does, but I can wrangle
my thoughts, words, and actions into alignment with what I believe about how we
should treat one another in civil society. David Brooks wrote an opinion piece
in today’s New York Times that resonated with me and I will close with his
last four paragraphs:
“Nobody has emerged
unscathed. Those of us in the anti-Trump camp will be smiled upon by history I
imagine, but we might pause for a moment to consider the mote in our own eye.
Our own sins are the only ones we can control.
Over the past four years we've poured out an hourly flow of anti-Trump diatribes and in almost every case they rise to the top of the charts--most liked, most retweeted, most read.
Even when justified, permanent indignation is not a healthy emotional state. We've become a little addicted to our own umbrage, addicted to that easy feeling of moral superiority, addicted to the easy affirmation bath we get when we repeat what we all believe. Trump-bashing has become a business model. Politics has become a way to define and identify your identity, and that is elevating politics to too central a place in life. He's made life all about himself, and a lot of us too readily played along.
Here’s one thing we will never be able to shake, the awareness that our basic standards of decency are more fragile than we thought; the awareness that any year, some new leader may come along and bring us back to a world of no bottom.”